The Bone Store Logo

Pillows

The right pillow can make a big difference in how comfortable you feel when you settle into bed—and there isn't one pillow that's right for everyone. Your sleeping position, body shape, mattress, and personal preferences all affect the height, shape, and feel that may work best for you.

At The Bone Store, we believe choosing a pillow should be more personal than simply picking "soft" or "firm." Explore pillows with different shapes, materials, heights, and support characteristics, and let us help you find an option that feels comfortable for the way you actually sleep.

How to Choose the Right Pillow

A pillow may look simple, but small differences in height, shape, material, and firmness can completely change how it feels once you're lying down. The best place to start is with how you naturally sleep and how your pillow works together with your mattress and body.

Continue Reading

Start With Your Sleeping Position

Your usual sleeping position is one of the first things to consider when choosing a pillow. Side, back, and stomach sleeping place your head and neck in different positions relative to the mattress, so the pillow height and feel that works well for one sleeper may be uncomfortable for another.

If you change positions throughout the night, look for a pillow that feels comfortable in the positions you use most rather than trying to choose based on a single label or recommendation.

Pillow Height Matters

The height of a pillow—sometimes called its loft—affects where your head rests in relation to the rest of your body. A pillow that feels too tall can be just as uncomfortable as one that feels too flat.

Your ideal pillow height isn't determined by sleeping position alone. Shoulder width, body proportions, mattress firmness, and how deeply you settle into the mattress all influence how much space the pillow needs to fill.

Your Mattress Changes How Your Pillow Fits

Your pillow and mattress work together. On a softer mattress, your shoulders and body may settle farther into the sleep surface, changing the distance between your head and the mattress. On a firmer surface, your body may remain higher and create a different amount of space for the pillow to fill.

That's one reason a pillow that felt great on one mattress may feel completely different after changing mattresses.

Side Sleepers

When sleeping on your side, the pillow fills the space between your head and the mattress created by your shoulders. Shoulder width, mattress firmness, and how deeply your shoulder sinks into the mattress can all affect the pillow height that feels comfortable.

Some side sleepers also enjoy additional support elsewhere along the body. A body pillow or a pillow positioned between the knees may provide a more comfortable resting position depending on personal preference.

Back Sleepers

Back sleepers often look for a pillow that comfortably fills the space behind the head and neck without making the head feel excessively elevated. The shape of the pillow can be just as important as its overall thickness.

Contoured pillows, traditional-shaped pillows, and pillows with different support zones can all feel very different when lying on your back, which makes trying them particularly useful.

Stomach Sleepers

Because the head is typically turned to one side when sleeping on the stomach, some stomach sleepers prefer a lower-profile pillow or a softer pillow that compresses more easily beneath the head.

Personal preference and mattress feel still matter, so a pillow shouldn't be chosen by sleeping position alone.

Think Beyond Soft or Firm

Two pillows described as the same firmness can feel very different. Memory foam, specialty foams, fibers, and other materials respond differently to pressure and movement, while the pillow's shape and construction can affect how those materials feel beneath your head.

Instead of focusing only on whether a pillow is labeled soft, medium, or firm, consider how easily it compresses, how it responds when you change positions, and whether its shape feels natural to you.

Temperature Can Matter Too

If you tend to feel warm while sleeping, the materials and construction of your pillow may be important. Different foams, covers, ventilation designs, and temperature-management technologies can affect how a pillow handles heat and airflow.

Cooling features vary significantly by product, so look at the construction of the individual pillow rather than assuming all foam or specialty pillows will feel the same.

Shape Can Change the Experience

Not every pillow has to be a traditional rectangle with the same height from edge to edge. Contoured shapes, specialized profiles, and other designs can change how your head and neck rest on the pillow.

There isn't one shape that's automatically better. What matters is whether the design fits comfortably with your body, sleeping position, and personal preferences.

Pillows Aren't Just for Your Head

Pillows and positioning products can also be used elsewhere for comfort. Depending on your needs and preferences, body pillows, knee pillows, wedges, bolsters, and other specialty shapes can provide additional positioning options while sleeping or resting.

The appropriate size and shape depend on where you want the pillow positioned and what feels comfortable to you.

Give Yourself Time to Adjust

A new pillow can feel noticeably different from one you've slept on for months or years. The materials themselves may also change somewhat as a new pillow is used.

Give yourself time to become familiar with the new feel and follow the manufacturer's recommendations for use and care.

Try Your Pillow Before You Decide

Specifications can tell you the dimensions, materials, and features of a pillow, but they can't completely tell you how it will feel to you. Whenever possible, experiencing different pillow shapes and feels in person can help narrow down your choices.

Visit The Bone Store and let us help you compare your options. Rather than simply asking which pillow is "best," we'll help you think about how you sleep, what you're sleeping on, and what feels comfortable to you.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pillows

How do I know which pillow is right for me?

Start with your usual sleeping position, then consider your body proportions, mattress, preferred pillow feel, and any features that are important to you. Pillow height and shape can be just as important as firmness. Because comfort is personal, trying different options can be especially helpful when choosing a pillow.

What pillow height should I choose?

There isn't one ideal pillow height for everyone. Your sleeping position, shoulder width, body proportions, mattress firmness, and how deeply you settle into your mattress can all affect the height that feels comfortable. Rather than choosing by height alone, consider how the pillow positions your head when you're lying in your normal sleeping position.

What type of pillow is best for a side sleeper?

Side sleepers generally need a pillow that comfortably fills the space between the head and mattress created by the shoulders. The appropriate height depends on your shoulder width, body proportions, and how deeply you sink into your mattress. Because those factors vary from person to person, not every side sleeper needs the same pillow.

What type of pillow is best for a back sleeper?

Back sleepers often prefer a pillow that comfortably supports the head without making it feel excessively elevated. Pillow height, firmness, and shape can all affect the feel. Traditional and contoured pillows may provide very different experiences, so personal preference is important.

What type of pillow is best for a stomach sleeper?

Some stomach sleepers prefer a lower-profile or more compressible pillow because the head is generally turned to one side while sleeping. Mattress firmness, body proportions, and personal preference still matter, so sleeping position should be treated as a starting point rather than a rule.

What if I sleep in more than one position?

Many people change positions during the night. If you're a combination sleeper, consider how a pillow feels in the positions you use most and how easily you can reposition on it. A pillow that feels comfortable when you move between your preferred sleeping positions may be more useful than choosing one designed around a single position.

Does my mattress affect which pillow I should use?

Yes. Your mattress affects how deeply your shoulders and body settle into the sleep surface, which changes the space between your head and the mattress. A pillow that works well with one mattress may therefore feel taller or flatter when used with a different mattress.

What is pillow loft?

Loft generally refers to the height or thickness of a pillow. A higher-loft pillow creates more height beneath the head, while a lower-loft pillow creates less. The amount of loft that's comfortable for you depends on factors such as sleeping position, body proportions, mattress feel, pillow construction, and personal preference.

Are memory foam pillows hot?

Not all memory foam pillows handle temperature the same way. Foam formulation, ventilation, pillow construction, covers, and cooling technologies can all influence how a particular pillow manages heat and airflow. If sleeping temperature is important to you, compare the cooling and ventilation features of the specific pillows you're considering.

What's the difference between a traditional and contoured pillow?

A traditional pillow generally has the familiar rectangular shape and a relatively consistent profile. A contoured pillow uses changes in shape or height to create different areas for positioning the head and neck. Neither style is automatically better—the right choice depends on your sleeping position, body, mattress, and comfort preference.

Can I wash my pillow?

It depends on the pillow. Some covers may be removable and washable even when the pillow itself is not, while other materials have specific cleaning requirements. Always follow the care instructions provided by the manufacturer for your particular pillow.

How often should I replace my pillow?

There isn't one replacement schedule that applies to every pillow. Materials, construction, use, and care all affect how a pillow wears over time. Consider replacement when the pillow no longer maintains its intended shape or support, has become damaged, or simply no longer feels comfortable for you.

Why does my new pillow feel different from the one I tried?

A new pillow may need some time to reach its normal feel, and your body may also need time to adjust to a different pillow shape, height, or material. Room temperature can affect the feel of some foam products as well. Follow the manufacturer's instructions and allow an appropriate adjustment period for the particular pillow.

Can I return a pillow if I don't like it?

For health and hygiene reasons, sleep products are generally non-returnable. Because return and warranty terms can vary by product, please ask us about the policy for the specific pillow you're considering before purchasing.

Can The Bone Store help me choose a pillow?

Yes. Visit The Bone Store and we'll help you compare pillow heights, shapes, materials, and features based on how you sleep and what feels comfortable to you. When samples are available, experiencing the differences in person can make choosing between pillows much easier.

EXPERIENCE COMFORT & QUALITY TODAY

Your Nearest Bone Store

The Bone Store - Visalia

4128 S. Mooney Blvd
Visalia, California 93277
559-739-7500

Get Directions

Keep in contact with us to receive more exclusive offers!

Fresno Store Hours: Monday - Friday 9am to 6pm | Saturday 10am to 5pm | Closed Sunday

Bakersfield, Stockton & Visalia Store Hours: Monday - Friday 10am to 6pm | Saturday 10am to 5pm | Closed Sunday

Have a Question? Give us a call!

Bakersfield 661-846-7500 | Fresno  559-226-7500 | Stockton 209-720-7500 | Visalia 559-739-7500